Is the TSP Better Than a 401(k)? The $15,850 Fee Gap on a $100,000 Balance
You're a federal employee, and a coworker in the private sector just bragged about their 401(k) match. You have the TSP instead. Is their plan better than yours — or is yours the better deal?
For most federal employees, the TSP wins on cost — and the gap is bigger than the percentages suggest. In 2025, every TSP fund charged between 0.034% and 0.051% a year. The average equity fund inside a 401(k) charged 0.26%. On a $100,000 balance, that gap is $225 a year — and about $15,850 over 20 years.
But fees are only one leg of the comparison. The match, the G Fund, and what happens when you leave federal service all change the answer. This guide prices each one in dollars, so you can decide for your situation instead of taking a slogan's word for it.
The Short Answer: Same Machine, Cheaper Parts
The TSP is the federal government's version of a 401(k), with the same tax choices and the same contribution limits.
It covers federal civilian employees and members of the uniformed services. Like a 401(k), it offers traditional (pre-tax) and Roth (after-tax) contributions, and the 2026 elective-deferral limit — $24,500, or $32,500 if you are 50 or older and $35,750 if you are 60 to 63 — applies to both plans. If you hold a TSP and a 401(k) in the same year, that limit covers the two combined, not each one separately.
The plan is large: average net assets across all TSP funds were about $1,006 billion in 2025, according to the Federal Retirement Thrift Investment Board. So the question "which is better" is mostly a question about the wrapper — fees, match, fund menu, and what happens when you leave.
The Fee Gap in Dollars, Not Percentages
On a $100,000 balance, the TSP's C Fund costs $35 a year. The average equity fund in a 401(k) costs $260.
The TSP publishes its expense ratios every year. For 2025, the five core funds ran from 0.034% (G Fund) to 0.051% (S Fund), and the average across all TSP funds was 0.039%. The TSP notes that, as of January 2026, less than 1% of the roughly 170,000 funds tracked by FactSet had lower expense ratios than the TSP's funds.
Small percentages compound into real money. Take a $100,000 balance, a 7% gross annual return, and 20 years. The 7% is an assumption to show the maths, not a forecast — real returns vary and can be negative.
At the TSP's 0.035% C Fund fee, the balance grows to about $384,400. In the average 401(k) equity fund at 0.26%, it grows to about $368,600. The gap is about $15,850 — from a fee difference of 0.225 percentage points.
And the average hides a wide spread. When every plan counts equally instead of being weighted by assets, a study of large private-sector 401(k) plans found the average plan's total cost was 0.74% a year. At that cost, the same $100,000 grows to about $336,800 — a gap of about $47,600 against the TSP over 20 years.
One honest caveat: the 0.26% is an asset-weighted average, and big-employer plans can be nearly as cheap as the TSP. Index equity mutual funds averaged 0.05% across the industry in 2025, according to the Investment Company Institute — so a 401(k) full of index funds can nearly match the TSP. The fee gap bites hardest in smaller plans with expensive fund menus, which is exactly where most people never look.
How to check your own plan: your fee disclosure (the 404(a)(5) notice your employer must send each year) lists every fund's expense ratio. Compare it with the table above before deciding anything else.
Run Your Own Numbers: Compound Growth Calculator
The Match: 5% Is Simple Arithmetic
Contribute 5% of your pay and your agency adds 5% — a 10% total deposit every pay period.
The agency money comes in two pieces. First, an automatic contribution of 1% of your basic pay, every pay period, whether or not you contribute anything. Second, a match: dollar for dollar on the first 3% you contribute, then 50 cents on the dollar for the next 2%. At 5%, the match is 4%, and 1% automatic plus 4% matching is 5% from your agency.
On an $80,000 salary, 5% from you is $4,000 a year — and 5% from your agency is another $4,000. Contribute nothing and the agency still deposits $800 a year from the automatic 1%, but you leave the $4,000 match behind.
New hires have been automatically enrolled at 5% since October 2020, so many federal employees already get the full match without ever choosing it. Check that you never lowered it. Members of the uniformed services under the Blended Retirement System get the same structure, with matching starting after two years of service. Employees under the older Civil Service Retirement System get no match at all — their pension is the tradeoff.
The vesting trap sits inside the automatic 1%. Your own contributions and the matching dollars are yours immediately. The automatic 1% — and everything it earns — only becomes yours after three years of federal civilian service for most FERS employees (two years for uniformed service members and certain positions). Leave at two years and eleven months and that slice goes back to the plan.
A private-sector match varies by employer, and a match above 5% can beat the TSP on this leg. The match is the one place where a good 401(k) can outscore the TSP — which is why the match, not the brand name, is the number to compare.
The G Fund Has No 401(k) Equivalent
The G Fund is the one TSP feature a 401(k) cannot copy: a fund that cannot lose principal and still pays a Treasury yield.
It holds special-issue Treasury securities available only to the TSP. Its interest rate is set by law from the average yield of Treasury securities with more than four years to maturity, and its share price never falls. No 401(k) fund offers that combination.
The closest analogue in a 401(k) is a stable-value fund — but those are insurance contracts with their own fees and withdrawal restrictions, and they do not carry the same guarantee. The G Fund's tradeoff is the other direction: it will not keep up with stocks over long periods, so it is a parking place and a stabilizer, not a growth engine.
Where a Good 401(k) Can Win
The TSP's weakness is choice: five core funds plus Lifecycle funds, and little else unless you pay extra for the mutual fund window.
- A wider menu: A typical 401(k) offers 15 to 30 or more funds, sometimes with a brokerage window. The TSP offers the G, F, C, S, and I funds plus Lifecycle funds — and a mutual fund window that carries additional annual fees.
- A bigger match: Some private employers match more than the TSP's 5%, which can outweigh the TSP's fee edge.
- The pension underneath: FERS employees also get a pension and Social Security, so the TSP is one of three legs. Comparing the TSP alone against a 401(k) alone understates a federal employee's retirement package.
- The vesting clock: The automatic 1% is the only TSP money with a vesting wait, and a private 401(k) match has its own vesting schedule — check both before changing jobs.
The Three Decisions That Actually Matter
Most "TSP vs. 401(k)" articles end with "it depends." These three situations say what it depends on.
1. You work for the federal government now
Contribute at least 5% — that is the whole decision for most people. Every point below 5% leaves matching money behind, and the match is an immediate return on those dollars that no fund can promise. If you were auto-enrolled at 5%, check that you never lowered it. If you are deciding between the TSP and a Roth IRA for your next dollar, our guide to retirement accounts walks through the order to fund them.
2. You are leaving federal service
Leaving the money in the TSP keeps the low fees and the G Fund. Rolling it into an IRA buys more fund choice at a higher price — and it gives up two things: the G Fund, and the age-55 separation-from-service exception, which lets employer-plan money come out without the 10% early-withdrawal penalty if you separate in the year you turn 55. An IRA makes you wait until 59½. Before rolling anything, compare your new 401(k)'s actual expense ratios and match rather than assuming it is cheaper — and if you do roll a 401(k) into an IRA, watch the 20% withholding trap that catches most people. What happens to a 401(k) when you quit covers the same choices from the private-sector side.
3. You hold both a TSP and a 401(k)
Put the next dollar where the match is bigger and the fees are lower — and remember the $24,500 elective-deferral limit for 2026 covers both plans combined, so you cannot max out each one separately. If your 401(k) has no match, the TSP usually wins the next dollar on fees alone.
See What Fees Do to Your Balance: Compound Growth Calculator
Key Takeaway
The TSP is not magic — it is a 401(k) with cheaper parts and one fund nothing else offers. For a federal employee who contributes 5%, it is hard to beat on cost: about $35 a year per $100,000 in the C Fund, against $260 in the average 401(k) equity fund, and a 5% agency contribution on top.
The decision that matters most is not which plan is "better" — it is whether you are getting the full 5% match and keeping your fees near the TSP's level wherever the money sits.
Sources
• Thrift Savings Plan, "Expenses and fees," tsp.gov — tsp.gov/expenses-and-fees
• Investment Company Institute, "The Economics of Providing 401(k) Plans: Services, Fees, and Expenses, 2024" — ici.org (PDF)
• Investment Company Institute / ISS Market Intelligence, "The Defined Contribution Plan Profile: A Close Look at 401(k) Plans, 2023" (plan-weighted 0.74% total cost figure)
• Federal Retirement Thrift Investment Board, "TSP Annual Review of Administrative Expenses," January 2026 — frtib.gov (PDF)
• Thrift Savings Plan, "Contribution types," tsp.gov (match formula and vesting rules)
• IRS News Release IR-2025-111 (2026 contribution limits: $24,500; $32,500 at 50+; $35,750 at 60–63)

Comments
Post a Comment